Nov 19, 2026: a 23% drop that built through the morning
StoneX released its results after the close on Nov 18. The stock first rose to $55.10 at 4:05pm, 2.4% above the close, then fell to $50.50 by 4:50pm, 6.2% lower, as investors read past the record-year headline to the quarter. Premarket trading on Nov 19 drifted down to $49.01 by 9:25am, 9.0% below the close.
The 9am call did not stop the slide. The stock opened at $48.70, touched $49.67, and then fell steadily to $41.19 by late morning, 23.5% below the close. At 11:53am it was $41.21, down 23.4%, on 1.8 million shares, almost twice a normal full day's volume.
What pushed it down:
- An earnings miss. Diluted earnings of $0.66 a share missed the $0.81 consensus cited by Investing.com and an $0.86 consensus in another survey. Net income fell 2% to $84.2 million even though pretax income rose 10%, because income tax expense rose 51% to $35.4 million.
- A shrinking Institutional segment. Segment income fell 25% to $98.9 million. Smith said fiscal 2026 was still "a record year for the institutional segment," but the fourth quarter was weaker than the third by 22%, and group president Charles Lyon said the fixed income desk is "very rate-sensitive."
- Narrower spreads and weaker retail trading. Securities revenue per million fell 23% despite 17% more volume, which finance chief Bill Dunaway put down to "the narrowing of spreads across both equity and fixed income products." Self-Directed/Retail income fell 56% to $6.4 million as foreign exchange and contract-for-difference volumes dropped.
Financial stocks did not fall with it. The Financial Select Sector SPDR fund was down 1.2% at 11:53am, Interactive Brokers 0.5%, MarketAxess was flat, and Robinhood and Virtu rose, so this was a StoneX move, not a sector one. Our explainer on why estimate revisions move stocks covers how a miss resets the numbers analysts carry forward, and the rest of the day's movers are in today's biggest stock moves.
After the drop, RSI(14) stood at 20, the shares sat 32% below their 50-day average and 38% below their 200-day average, volume by midday ran 1.9 times the 20-day average, and the stock was 56% below its split-adjusted 52-week high of $94.66 from June 22.
The numbers
| Measure | Q4 fiscal 2026 | Q4 fiscal 2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Operating revenues | $1,460.5M | $1,202.3M | +21% |
| Net operating revenues | $655.2M | $585.1M | +12% |
| Income before tax | $119.6M | $109.2M | +10% |
| Net income | $84.2M | $85.7M | -2% |
| Diluted EPS | $0.66 | $0.70 | -6% |
| Return on equity | 11.6% | 15.2% |
Two smaller items also hurt the quarter. Interest and fee income on client balances fell $12.3 million, mainly because of a $17.9 million unrealized loss on Treasury and agency bonds held in the investment portfolio, against a $9.0 million gain a year earlier. Fixed costs rose 9%, about $12 million of that from acquisitions. Professional fees fell 54% thanks to insurance and legal recoveries, which will not repeat every quarter.
StoneX completed three-for-two stock splits on March 20 and July 17, 2026, and every per-share figure here reflects both. Our explainer on whether stock splits move a stock covers why they change the share count but not the value.
The bull case
The full year was the best in the company's history: net operating revenues rose 43% to $2.9 billion and net income 72% to $525.4 million, helped by the R.J. O'Brien futures brokerage, acquired in July 2025, which added $195.8 million of operating revenue in the quarter. The Commercial segment, which serves producers and users of commodities, grew income 66%. Average client equity rose 26%, and listed derivative volumes rose sharply. At $41.21 the shares trade at about 9.9 times trailing earnings and about 1.7 times the $24.24 net asset value per share Zacks reported, and the consensus analyst target is $81, with a median of $65. Our explainer on return on equity covers why a business earning 19.5% on equity for the year can justify a premium to book value.
The risks
- The Institutional slowdown. The segment, which includes fixed income and equity market making, brought in $859.7 million of the quarter's $1,460.5 million of operating revenue, and both its net revenue and its income fell from the June quarter.
- Return on equity. The quarterly figure fell to 11.6% from 15.2%, and the tangible figure to 15.5% from 20.6%. A lower return on a larger equity base argues for a lower multiple of book value.
- Rates. Dunaway said a 100 basis point move in short-term rates changes annual net income by about $42.3 million, or $0.34 a share, and the firm added $150 million of interest rate swaps in the quarter.
- Momentum. The stock had fallen 20% from its Oct 5 close of $67.43 before the report. Our explainer on post-earnings drift covers why prices often keep moving in the direction of a surprise for weeks.
What comes next
- The annual report on Form 10-K. It will carry the full segment and risk detail for fiscal 2026.
- The Fed's rate decision, Dec 9. Short-term rates drive the interest StoneX earns on client balances.
- First-quarter results, expected around Feb 3, 2027. The consensus is $1.13 a share on about $1.44 billion of operating revenue, and the Institutional segment will show whether the fourth quarter was a dip or a trend.

