What the exchange asked for
In 2022 the exchange reorganized its markets into Prime, Standard and Growth. A follow-up council then looked at why so many listed companies were valued below their net assets. Its conclusion was that many companies did not treat cost of capital as a constraint and held assets that earned less than shareholders required.
The March 2023 request asked companies to do three things:
- Assess their current position, including return on equity, cost of capital and price-to-book ratio.
- Plan how to improve, with targets and a timeline, and disclose it.
- Act and update, revisiting the plan and disclosure each year.
The exchange stressed that a price-to-book ratio below 1.0 was a sign that the market did not expect the company to earn its cost of capital. Price-to-book explained covers why that is.
What it changed
| Date | Event | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| April 2022 | Market reorganized into Prime, Standard and Growth | Set the segments the request later targeted |
| March 2023 | Request on cost of capital and share price | Companies asked to disclose and act on plans |
| August 2023 | Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry issued new guidelines for corporate takeovers | Boards expected to consider bona fide proposals seriously |
| January 2024 | Exchange began publishing a monthly list of companies that had disclosed plans | Turned a request into a visible scorecard |
| 2024 to 2025 | Unsolicited proposals for large companies, including Alimentation Couche-Tard's approach to Seven & i Holdings, withdrawn in July 2025 | Showed that large Japanese companies could receive and must consider bids |
The list was the turning point. Investors could see which companies had responded and which had not. Activists cited the request in letters and proxy campaigns. Companies that had not disclosed a plan faced questions at annual meetings.
How companies responded
The responses fell into a few groups.
Capital returns. Buybacks and dividend increases were the fastest lever. Some companies adopted payout targets tied to book value, such as a dividend on equity ratio, which sets a floor that does not fall with a bad year.
Cross-shareholding sales. Many companies announced plans to reduce stakes in banks, insurers and business partners. Cross-shareholding unwinds in Japan covers how those sales work and what they release.
Return targets. Medium-term plans began to include return-on-equity targets above estimated cost of equity, often 8% or more.
Restructuring. Some companies sold non-core units, closed low-return operations or merged listed subsidiaries back into the parent.
Going private. Parents bought out listed subsidiaries, founders and private equity took companies private, and management buyouts rose. Going-private transactions explains the mechanics.
Why it is a special situation
A company trading below book value with surplus cash and listed stakes is a classic special situation in any market. What the push added was a reason to expect the gap to close and a calendar for it: annual plan updates, results releases and the June annual general meeting season.
The checks are the same as in any discount to assets. Holding company discounts and net cash per share set out the arithmetic. The Japanese version adds a step: reading the company's cost-of-capital disclosure and judging whether the plan is real.
Why the gap existed
The low valuations had several roots, and a plan is credible only if it addresses the ones that apply.
Cash balances. Many Japanese companies held large net cash positions earning close to zero. When the market values cash at a discount because it does not expect it to be returned, the company trades below book even with a sound business.
Cross-shareholdings. Stakes in banks, suppliers and customers were held for relationships, not returns. They tie up capital, earn modest dividends and often vote with management.
Low returns on equity. A company earning a 5% return on equity against an estimated cost of equity of 7% or 8% destroys value on each yen it retains. Its shares should trade below book until returns rise or capital is returned.
Listed subsidiaries. Parent and subsidiary both listed creates conflicts for minority holders of the subsidiary and leaves value split across two share registers. Equity carve-outs and equity method investments explain how those stakes are valued.
Weak pressure. For decades, stable shareholders and few independent directors meant management faced little challenge. The 2014 Stewardship Code and the 2015 Corporate Governance Code began to change that, and the 2023 request added the exchange's own voice.
What to check in a company's plan
| Item | Credible | Weak |
|---|---|---|
| Diagnosis | States ROE, cost of equity and P/B in numbers | General words about improving value |
| Targets | Dated ROE and payout targets | No dates or numbers |
| Cross-holdings | Named stakes, amounts and timeline | "Will review as appropriate" |
| Capital use | Specific buyback or dividend policy | Cash kept for "future growth" without detail |
| Board | Independent directors, clear capital policy | Few outside directors, no policy |
| Follow-through | Updates show progress against prior targets | Plan rewritten each year with new targets |
The exchange itself has published examples of disclosures that investors found useful and ones they did not. Its follow-up materials are in English.
Where this goes wrong
- Paper plans. Many companies disclosed a plan that named no numbers and changed little. The list shows disclosure, not results.
- Cross-holdings that move, not disappear. Some stakes are sold to friendly holders, which reduces the reported figure without increasing the free float.
- Low-ball take-privates. When a parent or founder takes a company private, the price may only modestly exceed the market price. Minority protections are weaker than in Delaware, though the 2023 takeover guidelines and a 2019 guideline on fair M&A raised expectations for special committees.
- Currency. For investors outside Japan, yen moves can outweigh the stock's move.
- Timing. Improvement can take several annual cycles, and the market may re-rate quickly once a plan is announced, leaving little for later.
How to follow it
Japanese companies mostly have March fiscal year ends, so full-year results arrive in late April and May, often with new medium-term plans and capital policies. Annual general meetings cluster in late June, when shareholder proposals and director votes are decided.
Track the exchange's monthly list, company plans filed with results and the June meeting season. Activist campaigns often surface in the spring. The best newsletters for special situations compares services that cover catalysts like these, and the guide to research tools for international stocks covers where to find Japanese filings and data.
The bottom line
The Tokyo Stock Exchange's 2023 request asked companies to manage for cost of capital and share price, and to say how. Its force came from disclosure and the public list that followed. It led to more buybacks, cross-holding sales and take-private deals. The investment work is reading each plan for numbers, dates and follow-through, and separating the companies that act from those that only publish.

